We love a good conspiracy
The Covid-19 crisis has been a veritable medical lab producing a range of new theories to occupy our time, confirm our prejudices and justify our political positions. Although we can laugh (hopefully!) at the idea that the coronavirus was started by hand-sanitiser companies or Greta Thunberg in an attempt to deal with climate change, we have also seen in the news a darker trajectory that conspiracies can take – whether it is burning 5G towers or attacking Chinese nationals. So the question I have been pondering is why we gravitate so easily and quickly to conspiracy theories. Now I am sure that the reasons are manifold and that it is at least partly because we love a good story – just think of all the conspiracy shows that are available on Netflix and Amazon. However, I do have three other suggestions for you to consider.
Control. We live in a world where we can quite easily convince ourselves that we are in control and that if we are just sensible and careful we can manage all eventualities. The coronavirus has shattered that illusion on both a macro and a micro level. Nations and scientists scramble to find solutions while the best-laid plans of millions of individuals lie in tatters. In those moments it is far easier to cope with the idea that somebody (or some group) has intentionally sabotaged our controlled environment than to believe that our environment was never actually controlled in the first place. Plagues,viruses and wars have ravaged societies for as long as humanity has been around and will continue to impact us into the future. What we are experiencing is not new, it is just very new to a society that has lived incredibly stable, and increasingly affluent, lives over the last 70 years.
Blame. Having someone to blame – or even worse to hate – makes it easier to deal with our grief, misfortune and loss. We find it easier to blame a person than to hate a virus or to accept that sometimes bad and awful things just happen. History is full of examples of how conspiracies have created scapegoats that have enabled a) people to cope and make sense of their suffering and b) others to consolidate their political and ideological positions – consider the rise of anti-semitism in Nazi Germany as a great example.
Authority. A good conspiracy enables us to not only justify our suspicion of authority but also our rebellion against it – whether that is through our actions or more subtly in the posture of our hearts. This has the added benefit of reinforcing the validity of my own independent kingdom – after all who can you really trust! I would not suggest for a moment that blind acceptance of authority is a good thing but is an abject lack of trust a great alternative? We have become comfortable with a default of suspicion. The war cry of “Fake News” has perpetuated this trend and like all poison it may have an element of truth which makes it palatable before it slowly kills.
Now I appreciate that conspiracy theories can find a home across a wide range of society but as a pastor it sometimes feels like the church is particularly fertile ground. An article in Christianity Today (17 April 2020) stated that a recent survey showed that Christians across all demographics were more likely to believe that Covid-19 was created in a lab than the rest of the American public. To an extent this is not surprising because pretty near the centre of our faith is the belief that there is an unseen realm. If we combine that with the motifs of the “Kingdom of God” and “Spiritual Warfare” then we see that people of faith have a paradigm far more accommodating to believing that there is more going on than meets the eye. So how can we as Christians use such a paradigm in a way that is fruitful and life giving rather than in a way that promotes fear and suspicion:
- Reflect on the resurrection of Jesus. This world that we live in is broken and will exhibit brokenness until Jesus returns. The pain and suffering that takes place is not always because of forces of evil but also a result of sin which has caused the corruption of all creation – resulting in random acts which lash out and cause violence and pain. The stunning thing about the Christian faith is that we believe that God lovingly cares for this broken world – including you and I – so he came into the mess and absorbed the sin and corruption into himself and died on a cross as a result. BUT three days later he rose from the dead and in doing that he demonstrated the victory he has won for all creation. The resurrection is a demonstration that God is making all things new in Jesus. Yes in this world we will suffer but Jesus’ resurrection is a reminder that the story doesn’t ultimately end in our suffering, but in his victory.
- Remind yourself that God is sovereign. The sovereignty of God has been the cause of much debate in Christian circles but in its essence it is the belief that God is ultimately in control and you and I are not. That is a very good thing because we do not have the wisdom, power or love necessary to be in control, but God does. Furthermore, when we think we have to be in ultimate control it is a breeding ground for serious fear and stress. The good news is that God, who is loving and just, is sovereign and everything he desires will come to pass in a way which gives him glory and profoundly blesses his children and all creation. The tricky thing is that God may not always share his plans with us and we may not always know where the pillar of cloud or fire is leading but that is where trust and faith come in.
- Pray. Nothing demonstrates a recognition of a) our hope in the resurrection and b) our confidence in God’s sovereign power to accomplish his will quite like prayer. We pray for God to demonstrate his sovereign will in our lives, in our homes, in our city – even in the middle of the coronavirus.
- Ask yourself whether the conspiracy theories that we engage with give us peace and hope. Do they promote love and kindness? If they don’t, maybe we should turn our attention to the things that do.